If you’ve ever wondered about trying anal toys but didn’t know where to start, you’re definitely not alone. Anal toys can seem a bit intimidating at first—especially if you’re new to the whole idea. But the truth is, with the right approach and the right toy, anal play can be a whole new world of fun and pleasure.
Let’s be honest, we’ve all had those moments of curiosity (or maybe a few nerves) when considering something new in the bedroom. So, in this guide, we’re going to break it all down: from the best anal sex toys for beginners to helpful tips on how to get started comfortably and safely.
Shop this guide
6 in-stock picks, live prices
In this guide
Why Try Anal Toys?
You might be wondering, “Why even consider anal toys in the first place?” Well, it’s simple—they can add a new layer of sensation and excitement to your play, whether solo or with a partner. The anus has tons of sensitive nerve endings that, when stimulated, can feel amazing. And for those with a prostate, anal play can lead to incredible, intense orgasms.
According to a blog from Healthline, anal masturbation has some great benefits, including stress relief, improved sleep, and enhanced sexual exploration. Just like other forms of self-pleasure, exploring anal play allows you to discover new sensations, connect with your body, and improve your mood. Whether you choose to start with fingers or toys, the key is comfort and patience.
But don’t worry—if you’re new to this, we’ve got your back with beginner-friendly options designed to make everything feel easy and comfortable.
What to Look for in the Best Anal Toys for Beginners
Okay, so you’re interested, but how do you choose? When it comes to finding the best anal toys for beginners, there are a few key things to consider:
- Start Small : Trust me, size matters—especially when you’re new to anal play. Smaller toys are easier to manage and a lot more comfortable.
- Material : Go for body-safe materials like silicone, glass, or stainless steel. These are non-porous, easy to clean, and safe for your body.
- Shape : Make sure any toy you choose has a flared base. This is crucial for safety, so the toy doesn’t go in too far. (Yes, that’s a thing!)
- Simple Is Better : Stick with toys that are straightforward and easy to use. You can always level up once you feel more confident.
Ready to explore? Let’s dive into some of the best anal sex toys for beginners that check all the right boxes.
Best Anal Toys for Beginners
1. Beginner Butt Plugs
You’ve probably heard of butt plugs before—they’re one of the most popular choices for beginners. These little toys are designed to stay in place once inserted, making them great for hands-free play. Plus, they come in all shapes, sizes, and materials.
Why They’re Great for Beginners : Butt plugs are small, comfortable, and easy to use. They help you get used to the feeling of having something inside without requiring much movement.
Pro Tip : Start with a small silicone plug. It’s flexible, smooth, and super easy to clean!
2. Anal Beads
Anal beads are another great option for beginners. These toys consist of a string of beads that gradually increase in size, allowing you to control how much you want to insert. The sensation of removing them slowly can be surprisingly pleasurable.
Why They’re Great for Beginners : You get to start small and work your way up at your own pace, making them perfect for those new to anal play.
Pro Tip : Look for beads with a sturdy handle or loop at the end for easy retrieval.
3. Prostate Massagers
For the fellas out there, if you’ve got a prostate, prostate massagers are a game-changer. They’re specifically designed to stimulate the prostate, leading to intense, satisfying orgasms.
Why They’re Great for Beginners : Many beginner prostate massagers are small and curved to easily hit the right spot. They also come with a handle or base for easy control and safety.
Pro Tip : Choose a smooth, tapered shape for easy insertion and comfort.
4. Vibrating Butt Plugs
Once you’re feeling more comfortable, you might want to try adding some vibrations into the mix. Vibrating butt plugs offer that same gentle pressure, but with the added bonus of a buzz that can heighten the experience.
Why They’re Great for Beginners : The vibrations add an extra level of stimulation without overwhelming you. Plus, you can control the intensity and find what feels best.
Pro Tip : Start with the vibration on low until you’re used to the sensation, then ramp it up!
5. Slim Anal Dildos
For those who want to explore a little deeper, slim anal dildos are an option. These toys are similar to regular dildos but are often slimmer and designed specifically for anal play.
Why They’re Great for Beginners : Slim dildos give you the sensation of penetration without being too intense, allowing you to experiment at your own pace.
Pro Tip : Opt for smooth silicone or glass for an easy, comfortable glide.
Tips for Using Anal Toys as a Beginner
1. Lube, Lube, Lube
2. Take Your Time
3. Try Different Positions
4. Listen to Your Body
5. Safety First
Aftercare: The Final Step
Matching the Toy Type to the Feeling You Want
Once you know the main types, the easiest way to choose is to start with the sensation you are curious about, then pick the toy built for it.
- A steady, full feeling you can forget about: Butt plugs sit in place behind a flared base, so you can wear one during solo play, foreplay, or sex and keep your hands free.
- A slow build and a fun finish: Anal beads get you used to one bead at a time, and many people enjoy the release of easing them out right around orgasm.
- In-and-out movement: Anal dildos are made for thrusting. Look for a slim, smooth shaft and a wide base, and keep the lube close.
- Prostate pleasure: Prostate stimulators have a curved tip aimed toward the front wall of the rectum, where the prostate sits, plus a handle or base that keeps them in place.
- A little extra buzz: Plugs, beads, and prostate toys all come in vibrating versions. Begin on the lowest setting and work up, and browse vibrating plugs for beginners and beyond when you are ready.
Whichever type you pick, the same rules apply: a flared base or retrieval loop, a body-safe material, and a size smaller than you think you need. Not sure which material to choose? Read silicone vs glass anal toys, and when you are ready to go further, see anal toys for advanced users.
Your First Session, Step by Step
- Prep: Wash the toy and your hands. A warm shower or bath first can help your muscles let go.
- Lube both sides: Coat the toy and your body generously, and add more whenever things start to drag. A thicker anal lube tends to last longer.
- Get comfortable: Lying on your side with your knees pulled up, squatting, or standing with one foot on the edge of the bed all make insertion easier.
- Start at the surface: Press the tip against your body and breathe slowly until you feel yourself relax, then let it slide in a little at a time.
- Explore, then stop while it feels good: Try gentle movement or just leave it still. If anything pinches or hurts, pause, add lube, or try again another day.
One more hygiene tip: if you share a toy or move from anal to vaginal play, put a fresh condom on it, or wash it thoroughly before switching.
Final Thoughts: The Best Anal Toys for Beginners
Trying something new—like anal toys —doesn’t have to be scary. With the right toy, proper preparation, and a little patience, you can discover a whole new world of pleasure that’s both exciting and enjoyable. Whether you’re starting with a beginner butt plug, testing out some anal beads, or exploring prostate stimulation, the key is to choose toys that are specifically designed for beginners and to take things at your own pace.
Above all, have fun with it! The journey of discovering what you like is part of the excitement. So grab that lube, pick a toy, and get ready for a new adventure.
Happy exploring!
